50% OFF
18 months no interest or payments**
*Offer ends June 30, 2024
Request Appointment
I agree to the terms and conditions.

By clicking Get a Free Quote, you authorize NEWPRO Home Solutions to reach out to you with questions about your project, via phone, email, or text. Message/data rates apply. Consent is not a condition of purchase. You may unsubscribe at any time. Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy.


Metal Roofing vs. Shingles

Home with metal roofing

Asphalt shingles are far and away the most popular residential roofing material, as they offer a combination of affordability, curb appeal, and weather protection that is hard to match. Metal roofing is also popular among homeowners, as it provides reliable protection for a much longer lifespan than most other materials. If you’re planning to replace the roof on your New England home and trying to decide between metal and asphalt shingles, the roofing experts at NEWPRO have put together a guide to help answer some of your questions, so you can make the right choice for your home.

Which Option Is Right For Your Home?

When selecting the ideal roofing material for your new roof, it’s all about priorities. Asphalt shingle and metal roofs both have pros and cons, so the “right” option for you ultimately comes down to a few factors:


Metal roofing costs more upfront than asphalt shingles, which may eliminate it as an option for homeowners with a tight budget. However, if you have the extra funds or are willing to finance a larger number, a metal roof can be cost-effective over the long term.

And don’t let the lower price make you think that asphalt shingles are somehow an inferior product, as they’re a great option for residential roofs.


It’s hard to beat the dimensional appearance of architectural shingles, which use a variety of colors to create a natural look that greatly boosts your home’s curb appeal. They can mimic the look of wood shakes or slate and come in a wide array of shades.

One of the popular cons of metal roofing systems has been the appearance, which in the past has looked plain and industrial. However, metal roof design has made great strides, and you can now choose from a wide array of profiles, styles, and colors when designing your roof.


This is the area where metal roofing distinguishes itself from the crowd. When properly maintained, a metal roof has a lifespan of 50 years or more, meaning it would likely be the last roof you ever have to install on your home. Of course, the climate where the home is located plays a factor in the life of a metal roof and how soon you’d need a roof replacement.

Asphalt roofs also offer impressive longevity, but they usually need to be replaced every 20-30 years, depending on the type of shingles and the climate.

Weather Resistance

Asphalt roofs are designed to withstand weather conditions such as heavy rains, ice, snow, and strong winds, but they have their limits. They can be damaged by hail, falling branches, and wind-blown debris, and high winds can sometimes loosen shingles or rip them off completely. Metal roofs offer greater extreme weather protection, as they provide excellent impact resistance and withstand strong winds. Metal roofs are also impervious to fire and aren’t affected by freeze/thaw cycles.

Roof Maintenance Requirements

If your home has an asphalt shingle roof that’s 10+ years old, it’s a good time to start having yearly inspections to look for issues like loose shingles or deteriorated seals, which can lead to leaks. It’s also a good idea to have a metal roof inspected yearly to look for scratches, damaged flashing, loose panels, or any blemishes that might signal underlying damage. Although high-quality metal roofs are low maintenance, they do require a regular check of the metal roofing panels.

Energy Efficiency

New home with metal roof

A lot of homeowners seem to think that a metal roof will retain more heat than a shingle roof, but the opposite is true. Metal roofs reflect much of the sun’s energy, keeping attic temperatures cooler and making it easier for your HVAC system to do its job. Ultimately, this results in energy savings for you in the form of a lower energy bill. Asphalt roofs tend to absorb more heat, so it’s important to have excellent attic insulation and ventilation to help keep energy costs down.


Metal roofing is thought to be more eco-friendly for two reasons. First, metal roofs usually contain a larger percentage of recycled materials. Additionally, they last longer than asphalt shingle roofs, so they don’t need to be disposed of in landfills as often.

Making the Right Decision for Your Home

If you plan to be in your home for the long term and can afford a little more, a metal roof might be the right choice for your roofing project. However, if you think you might want to sell your home sometime in the not-too-distant future, an asphalt shingle roof can provide excellent performance and a great resale value for your home. The best type of roof for you depends on your circumstances.

NEWPRO Offers High-Performance Asphalt Shingle & Metal Roofing Options

Now that you’ve read about the various benefits offered by asphalt shingle and metal roofing, NEWPRO is ready to install the ideal roofing system for your New England home. We offer metal and asphalt shingle roofing products from top manufacturers, and our factory-trained technicians know how to do the job right the first time.

Contact NEWPRO today to learn more.

December 13, 2023
Roof Replacement, Roofing, Roofing Company,

Featured Testimonials

Siding, Roofing & Window Replacement Project

It honestly looks like a brand new home!

We've already noticed the benefits of our new roofing, siding, and windows. Everything just looks great so we're super happy.

North Attleboro, MA

Window Replacement Project

The window, since it's been replaced, has been awesome.

Portsmouth, NH

Pool House Doors Project

Cold stays out in the winter. Cold stays in during the summer.

The best thing I love is the craftsmanship from NEWPRO. You'd never know we had the old door cut out because it was rotted from the New England weather.

Scott Zolak

Roof Replacement

The work is awesome and they know what they're doing.

I don't have to worry, I have the assurance from NEWPRO. If you need a new roof, please call NEWPRO!

Hyde Park, MA

Bath to Shower Conversion

Our installer kept us informed every minute of the day and was so considerate.

Our whole bathroom looks so much bigger and brighter and is so beautiful. It made everything look so much cleaner!

Peabody, MA

Elite Bath

With the new shower installer, it feels so much bigger and it so beautiful.

We've got great storage and it's so easy to clean now too!

Marc Bertrand
Hanover, MA

LuxLife Flooring Replacement

During the consultation, we were very happy with how it was presented.

We love the color of the floors. It's a much better material and it's going to be beautiful no matter what. It's perfect for my two dogs too.

North Smithfield, RI

A Reputation You Can Trust

It’s easy to see what makes NEWPRO New England’s go-to home improvement company.

  • Since 1945third-generation, family-operated
  • 350k+ Smilesby happy homeowners in the New England area
  • 75+ Yearsof quality home remodeling
  • 300+ Expertsat your service
Facebook Website
Better Business Bureau

Giving Back Is Integral to NEWPRO’s Culture

Giving Back Is Integral to NEWPRO’s Culture
  • Community Heroes
  • Baths for the Brave
  • Healthcare Heroes

Home Improvement is About Improving Lives

NEWPRO is proud to support worthy initiatives in the communities we serve. Through our exceptional products and services, we help those in need make upgrades to their homes that have a meaningful impact on their lives.

50% OFF Installation*
- + -
18 months no interest or payments** - *Offer ends June 30, 2024
Call Today